American Idol Platinum Ticket Bewilders Me

The judges on American Idol do a terrible job explaining what the platinum ticket is to the viewers at home. Actually, I take that back. The judges on American Idol don’t explain the platinum ticket at all! “Why should contestants be so excited about it?” is what I find myself asking each season.

---

The platinum ticket exempts the contestant from competing in the first Hollywood round which, if we’re being honest, may not be an advantage. I think of it in football terms. A team that does well in the season might get a first round bye in the playoffs. But this team which was in sync and firing on all cylinders might be thrown out of sync when they have a week off. In American Idol terms, these platinum ticket holders are dropped into the Hollywood round(s) fresh while the others have been in the swing of things already. This doesn’t seem like an advantage at all.

Also, the Hollywood rounds have been condensed into a two-night event (Sunday and Monday) for viewers at home so whatever happens, happens quickly. I think experiencing the first round really only helps you get stronger as a competitor and skipping that round might actually create a disadvantage. You’re less likely to gel with the other contestants, might have more nerves since round 2 is your first time performing since the audition.

In summary, the platinum ticket is an honor to receive but might restrict the contestant, not only setting up an unnecessary hurdle, but also making them have to get up to speed once they are officially back in the competition. Plus, the added pressure of being one of just three platinum ticket recipients eliminates any sort of underdog or black horse mentality.

-Out of the Wilderness